Sensory analysis - Methodology - General guidance for measuring odour, flavour and taste detection thresholds by a three-alternative forced-choice (3-AFC) procedure
Introduction: The concept of “threshold” has wide use in sensory analysis and is often used in the literature on sensory studies of food and drink. Data on sensory thresholds to stimuli are used in sensory studies in two main ways: as measures of the sensitivity of assessors or groups of assessors to specific stimuli; and as measures of the ability of substances to evoke sensory responses in assessors. In the first, the value of the threshold is taken as a description of an assessor’s performance; in the latter, as a measure of a property of the substance. The term “threshold” was introduced by 19th century psychophysicists and used to denote a stimulus concentration above which the stimulus could be detected, and below which it could not [see Figure 1 a)]. a) Traditional notion of threshold b) Probabilistic nature of threshold Key concentration of stimulus, x probability of detection, pd threshold Figure 1 — Traditional notion and probabilistic nature of threshold However, in practice the graph of the probability of detection1) against the intensity of the stimulus is always an ogive [see Figure 1 b)], and it is convenient to assume, for purposes of calculation, that the threshold fluctuates so that a particular stimulus concentration exceeds it on some occasions but not on others. The threshold can then be obtained as an estimate of the median of these momentary values, i.e. as the stimulus concentration for which the probability of detection is 0,5. The threshold defined in this way has
Scope: This document gives guidelines for — obtaining data on the detection of stimuli that evoke responses to odour, flavour and taste by a 3-AFC (three-alternative forced-choice) procedure, and — the processing of the data to estimate the value of a threshold and its error bounds, and other statistics related to the detection of the stimulus. Typically, the procedures will be used in one of the following two modes: — investigation of the sensitivity of assessors to specific stimuli; — investigation of the ability of a chemical substance to stimulate the chemoreceptive senses. (Although experiments can encompass both modes.) Examples of the first mode include studies of the differences among individuals or specified populations of individuals in sensitivities and of the effects of age, gender, physiological condition, disease, administration of drugs and ambient conditions on sensitivity. Examples of the latter mode include — studies in flavour chemistry and the impact of specified chemicals on the flavour of foods, — classification of chemicals for their impact on humans, if present in the environment, — studies on the relationship of molecular structure to capacity of a chemical to act as a stimulant, — quality assurance of gaseous effluents and of water, foods and beverages, and — studies in the mechanism of olfaction. In both modes, the way in which probability of a correct response changes with intensity of stimulus, i.e. the slope of the dose/response curve, could be an important aspect of the study as well as the threshold value, and the data processing procedures described here provide this information. The focus of this document is on data requirements and on computational procedures. Regarding the validity of the data, the text is restricted to general rules and precautions. It does not differentiate between detection and difference thresholds; fundamentally, the procedures measure a difference threshold because a test sample is compared with a reference sample. Typically, the reference sample is not intended to contain the stimulus under investigation, but the guidelines do not exclude experimental design in which the reference could contain the stimulus, o