Statistical methods of uncertainty evaluation - Guidance on evaluation of uncertainty using two-factor crossed designs
Introduction: Uncertainty estimation usually requires the estimation and subsequent combination of uncertainties arising from random variation. Such random variation may arise within a particular experiment under repeatability conditions, or over a wider range of conditions. Variation under repeatability conditions is usually characterized as repeatability standard deviation or coefficient of variation; precision under wider changes in conditions is generally termed intermediate precision or reproducibility. The most common experimental design for estimating the long- and short-term components of variance is the classical balanced nested design of the kind used by ISO 5725-2. In this design, a (constant) number of observations are collected under repeatability conditions for each level of some other factor. Where this additional factor is ‘Laboratory’, the experiment is a balanced inter-laboratory study, and can be analysed to yield estimates of within-laboratory variance, σ r 2 , the between-laboratory component of variance, σ L 2 , and hence the reproducibility variance, σ . Estimation of uncertainties based on such a study is considered by ISO 21748. Where the additional grouping factor is another condition of measurement, however, the between-group term can usefully be taken as the uncertainty contribution arising from random variation in that factor. For example, if several different extracts are prepared from a homogeneous material and each is measured several times, analysis of vari
Scope: This Technical Specification describes the estimation of uncertainties on the mean value in experiments conducted as crossed designs, and the use of variances extracted from such experiments and applied to the results of other measurements (for example, single observations). This Technical Specification covers balanced two-factor designs with any number of levels. The basic designs covered include the two-way design without replication and the two-way design with replication, with one or both factors considered as random. Calculations of variance components from ANOVA tables and their use in uncertainty estimation are given. In addition, brief guidance is given on the use of restricted maximum likelihood estimates from software, and on the treatment of experiments with small numbers of missing data points. Methods for review of the data for outliers and approximate normality are provided. The use of data obtained from the treatment of relative observations (for example, apparent recovery in analytical chemistry) is included.